06/14/2026
I get asked about finishes almost every commission I take and over the years my stance has changed on this topic. Since the invention of polyurethane, there has been this push to “bomb proof” your wood furniture. We’ve been sold on zero maintenance as the best option. However, like many things in life, it sounds too good to be true and it is. Plastic finishes can scratch just as easily as a raw wood surface, maybe easier actually because a scratch on plastic shows up white. And there in lies the big lie. Yes, a plastic finish will resist water virtually forever, that is until it gets scratched. How many of us have seen water rings on our furniture? That only comes from moisture seeping into the cracks of the finish and becoming trapped under the plastic coating. That finish will continue to fail in this way until you repair the finish which can only be done properly by applying a coat across the entire surface. Oil and wax, on the other hand, resists water and stains by soaking into the wood fibers itself, rather than sitting on top. While moisture may eventually absorb into the wood if left long enough, the moisture isn’t trapped and will wick away. Refreshing the finish after hard use is as easy as wiping on some more oil. Just think, when’s the last time you’ve seen a water ring on a cutting board. No wood item in your home gets more abuse than a cutting board. It’s exposed to water, stains from tomatoes and berries, fats from meats etc. to maintain them, we wash with soap and water and rub on more oil when the wood looks dry. My cutting board shown here is 8 years old and has never even been re-sanded. One pic shows the top and the other the bottom which looks almost as good as the day I made it. So, the next time the marketers want to sell you on a “bomb proof” “zero maintenance” finish, just remember there’s no such thing. It will look good for a while, but ALL finish requires maintenance at some point. The question is how hard do you want to work, and how much skill does it take to repair it. If you want to get even crazier, my last picture is of a display case built by my grandmother when I was a boy. It has no finish at all! Just pine and all its glory.